Mired in gas

By Mike Uretsky

My wife and I moved up here about fifteen years ago. We were attracted to this area because we had friends up here, it was a beautiful environment and the community was an interesting mix of people—some lifelong residents and some, like ourselves, part-time transplants. Since that time, and since retiring, I have become essentially a fulltime resident. I have gotten to know my neighbors quite well. I have more in common with some than with others, but we all respect each other’s individual rights. I believe that everyone owes something to the community they live in. Given my longstanding interest in the arts and the environment, I have been taking an active role in both the Delaware Valley Opera and the Delaware Highlands Conservancy.

The current natural gas situation has an impact on all of us. It will certainly (and rightly) benefit some people. We do not have a legal or moral right to impose our values on our neighbors. At the same time, it is coming and we will all be affected.

There are legitimate questions to be asked. What impact will gas exploration and development have on water, air and implicitly health? What impact is it likely to have on the local and national economy? How is it likely to affect real estate values? What impact is it likely to have on intangibles, e.g., beauty? These are all important questions—some more important to some people than others.

Given my concern, I embarked on my own investigations. They included sitting in on most of the meetings that have been held, consulting with environmental experts, doing web searches, speaking with petroleum engineers, speaking with gas and environmental lawyers, locating and speaking with people living in the “gas patch” out west, getting involved with other property owners and visiting gas fields here in Pennsylvania. I satisfied myself that I understand the issues, the benefits, the risks and the ways that these risks can be kept at a manageable level. Of equal significance, I satisfied myself that most of my neighbors who are looking into leasing some or all of their property are not money grubbers, but responsible members of our community who are cognizant of their neighbors, the environment and the community as a whole.

The current situation has the potential for tearing this community apart. The number of misstatements being made is shocking—especially in contrast with the academic environment from which I retired, in which accuracy and support of statements was an absolute requirement. Of equal significance, the misstatements are overshadowed by the personal rumors that are circulating. They are totally unfounded and unacceptable. If I were the focus of such rumors, my lawyer would respond.

We have a very special obligation to ourselves and each other. Just as there is freedom of speech, there are responsibilities associated with its exercise. You can’t yell fire in a crowded theater. Similarly, in this case, there is a real need to deal with substantiated facts and to keep the discussions from getting personal. Because of its reach, the press has a particularly important role to play. It must make sure that facts are checked and substantiated. It must provide a forum for keeping discussions on a high plain.

We have an obligation to exercise our first amendment rights in the interest of the community. People should sit down at the table and debate the facts. We can then look back at this shared experience and be proud of the fact that we have acted as mature, responsible adults who are interested in our community.

(Mike Uretsky is a retired faculty member at NYU, a resident of Damascus, a member of the board of the Delaware Valley Opera and Delaware Highlands Conservancy and a member of the Northern Wayne Property Owners Alliance.)

October 29, 2009 WES GILLINGHAM: The Catskills' future is up to us September 3, 2009 JEFFREY MOORE: Destroying it won't 'save'it August 6, 2009 BARBARA LEWIS: Trees: a legacy and a future July 9, 2009 SARAH CUTLER: Share the road June 11, 2009 SUSAN SCOTT: The democratization of information May 14, 2009 MICHAEL CHOJNICKI: A turning point April 16, 2009 JOHN CONWAY: Dual-mode transportation March 19,2009 KEITH LEPAN: NY H2O February 19, 2009 JEFFREY SEEDS: One-sidedness January 17, 2009 TOM HOLMES: Taking back the power December 25, 2008 TINA PALACEK: When a community is really a family November 27, 2008 STEPHANIE TURNER: Gas drilling from a realtor's perspective October 30, 2008 SUSAN SULLIVAN: From visiong to reality: the role of local government October 2, 2008 MARY BETH WOOD: Investing in career and technical education September 4, 2008 JOE LEVINE: When compromise is a recipe for disaster August 7, 2008 VIDAL MARTINEZ: The Upper Delaware experience July 10, 2008 WES GILLINGHAM: Sticking together June 12, 2008 LINDA COBB: The Harmony Project May 15, 2008 Barbara Arrindell: Looking back April 17, 2008 JO CLEARWATER: Welcome to the new world March 20, 2008 JONATHAN F. ROUIS: Out of many, one February 21, 2008 MIKE URETSKY: Mired in gas January 24, 2008 Some visionaries look at 2008 October 4, 2007 Greg Swarz: Coming Home September 6, 2007 Jim Serio: Educating the Delaware River Basin August 9, 2007 Stephanie Streeter: Still endangered? July 26, 2007 Molly Rodgers: Be informed, be connected July 12, 2007 Brad Krumholz: The landscape mind June 28, 2007 John Bunting: Milk price and power June 14, 2007 Brian Smith: It's time to work and worry May 31, 2007 Carol Roig: Celebrating history close to home May 17, 2007 Debbie Smorto: Be a part of the solution April 19, 2007 Robert Dadras: Creating a new direction for Sullivan County April 5, 2007 Dave Williams: Save your local dairy farm March 22, 2007 R.A. Dubensky: Losing our future March 8, 2007 Dave Williams: Save your local dairy farm February 22, 2007 Troy Bystrom: Conserve to preserve February 8, 2007 Alegra Jennings: Do you see what I see? January 18, 2007 Amy Gruzesk: A new alliance for business in Pike January 11, 2007 Grace Wildermuth: Our rural environment must be preserved December 28, 2006 John Jose: Meeting the challenges of stormwater management December 14, 2006 Daniel Kennedy: Making memories in Pike County November 30, 2006 Stephen Stuart: Sustainable Solutions November 16, 2006 Linda Cobb: The Harmony Project November 2, 2006 Judy Harlan: What municipalities can do about flooding October 19, 2006 Samuel Jackson: Walking the talk October 5, 2006 Jay Epstein: The foundations of a viable plan September 14, 2006 Tom Kane: The clean water act September 7, 2006 Skip Mendler: A community of communities August 24, 2006 FREDERICA LEIGHTON: Flood reality: vision or the lack of it August 10, 2006 DICK RISELING: A vision of actions July 27, 2006 PAT CARULLO AND MARCIA NEHEMIAH: Red plus blue equals green July 13, 2006 Neal Halloran: Greenway: a program whose time has come June 29, 2006 Steven Sharoff: Strong visions can change the world June 15, 2006 Heinrich Strauch: Cooking up a vision June 1, 2006 Jennifer C.S. Brylinski: The IDA keeps to its vision May 18, 2006 Norma and Bob Santee: Maintaining our environment May 4, 2006 Don Parry: The “vision thing” April 20, 2006 Joe Walsh: Keeping farms a mainstay of Sullivan County April 6, 2006 Heather Brown: Why I came here, and what keeps me here March 23, 2006 Pat Carullo: We are with the program March 09, 2006 Helen Budrock: The power of proactive thinking February 23, 2006 Carol Collier: A basin-wide collaboration February 9, 2006 Barbara Leo: A birding trail for the Upper Delaware January 26, 2006 Virginia Kennedy: Our vision—economic and environmental sustainability January 12, 2006 Tom Zeterburg: At the crossroads of two rivers December 29, 2005 Sally Corrigan: Hallmarks of a successful community December 15, 2005 “Better Models for Development” scores a hit - a compilation by Tom Kane and the Visioning Committee December 1, 2005 Brian Stuart: Protecting an amazing backyard resource November 17, 2005 John LiGreci: The need for a master plan November 3, 2005 Tom Kane: The need for intelligent land use practices October 20, 2005 Michael Chojnicki: The need for intelligent land use practices October 6, 2005 Alan Schadt: The Town of Highland through a crystal ball September 22, 2005 Ernie Mattern: Comprehensive Planning in Damascus September 8, 2005 Jerry DaBrescia: Visioning in Hancock August 25, 2005 Neal Halloran: Ways to secure open space August 11, 2005 Clem Fullerton: Flow woes August 11, 2005 Tom Kane: Options for preserving open space July 28, 2005 Charlie Buterbaugh: Fishing Days Gone July 28, 2005 George Fluhr: What's special about this place June 30, 2005 Tom Kane: There are many visions in the river valley June 30, 2005 Mary Curtis: My vision for the Upper Delaware River June 16, 2005 Sarah Sutto-Plunz: It depends on us June 16, 2005 Green buildings: a healthy revolution in the construction industry June 2, 2005 Pat Carullo: If horses can fly, rivers can speak! May 19, 2005 Laurie Stuart: A view from the ridge April 21, 2005 Rosie Starr: Preserving the Beauty of the Delaware River Valley April 7, 2005 Robert Burrow: Developing a plan takes study March 24, 2005 Tom Kane: Comprehensive Plan: The Key to the Future March 10, 2005 Katharine Dodge: We have a choice: aggressiveness or fairness February 24, 2005 Editorial: A tide in the affairs of men February 24, 2005 Jim Greier: Let’s not put our eggs in one basket February 10, 2005 Elliot Zucker: A voice for private property rights January 27, 2005 Steve Daley : Visions of business growth and home ownership January 13, 2005 Laura Quigley : Living and working in the land of plenty December 30, 2004 Dr. Martin Handler : My list of visions December 16, 2004 Dr. Bruce Getzan : Bringing harmony to contrasting visions December 2, 2004 Sally Talaga : Visioning’s first step November 18, 2004 Michele Ulmer : Be involved before it’s too late November 4, 2004 Marcia Nehemiah: It's all about the river October 21, 2004 John Drobysh: Balancing preservation with property rights October 7, 2004 Jeffrey Moore: Raising the standards in the river valley September 23, 2004 Dimitri Zaimes: The right and wrong of the Upper Delaware September 9, 2004 Frederica Leighton: Combining hindsight, foresight, present awareness and action August 26, 2004 Krista Gromalski: Turning the Conversation Up August 12, 2004 Jo Clearwater: Visioning July 29, 2004 Noel Van Swol: What about Property Rights? July 15, 2004 Cindy Wildermuth: A call for stewardship July 1, 2004 Tom Kane: Taking stock of the visioning process June 17, 2004 Dick Riseling: Sustainability and justice is at the heart of vision June 3, 2004 Peter Pinchot: Exurban sprawl or livable communities?